Save time spent searching, download the new Tripawds e-book for immediate answers!

Bookmark Jerry's Required Reading List for more amputation recovery advice and care tips.

Review the Tripawds Featured Blogs for the best three legged dog care product recommendations.

Tripawds is a user supported community. Please do what you can to help keep it online.

Tripawd Talk Radio Interview with Speaking for Spot Author Dr. Nancy Kay
Miss the show? Listen to the podcast now!

Please consider registering
guest

Log In RegisterMembers

Register | Lost password?
Advanced Search:

— Forum Scope —



— Match —



— Forum Options —




Wildcard usage:
*  matches any number of characters    %  matches exactly one character

Minimum search word length is 4 characters - maximum search word length is 84 characters

Topic RSS
Are all supplements created equal?
6 August 2010
5:01 pm
Cleveland, OH
Member
Forum Posts: 121
Member Since:
19 June 2010
Offline

I don't know how else to title this but if I need to give glucosamine and fish oil – - are all these supplements created equal?  I know some are WAY expensive while others are relatively inexpensive.  I do have a budget to stick to and I just see that Sam's Club has some pretty good pricing on Glucosamine for humans that fits my budget nicely.

 

I mention 'supplements' because there are SO many supplements out there – so I don't mean for just glucosamine, I also mean for this to go for the fish oil, mushrooms, and all the other supplements that our dogs take.

~~~~ Denali ~~~~ June 9, 2010 OSA suspected June 17, 2010, July 14, 2010 Clear X-rays – no mets July 1, 2010 Amputation July 9, 2010 OSA Confirmed November 23, 2010 Cancer took you from me - Never forgotten, Always Loved - Forever Supporting the Fighters, Admiring the Survivors, Honoring the Taken, And never, ever giving up Hope
6 August 2010
5:33 pm
Member
Forum Posts: 151
Member Since:
7 June 2010
Offline

I just picked up some 'just in case' meds for Charlie at Target. I actually had a nice conversation with the pharmacist (who helped me find some poison oak stuff for Mr. VQ). Anyway, the person before me asked for glucosomine supplements (I am assuming for humans). I would ask the pharmacist there (is there one at Sam's Club?) for what they recommend brand-wise. As far as dosage-wise, my vet tells me the amount to give him based on his weight. You can PM me, or I can post the dosage amounts I give to Charlie based on his weight.

"I don't know where I am."
6 August 2010
5:34 pm
Wesley Chapel, FL
Member
Forum Posts: 1111
Member Since:
13 September 2009
Offline

I know that the quality and amounts of glucosamine vary so much in all the brands.

I did some research when choosing what to get for Jake, since I was also on a very tight budget and wanted the most glucosamine for the buck! I compared all the products, and the amounts of ingredients and the monthly costs. I chose Joint Max Triple Strength Soft Chews. They were around $25 for 120 chews. Each chew was supposed to contain 1000mg of glucosamine and I was giving Jake 2 chews for maintenance. For the first 2-3 weeks, I was giving him 3 chews. I read somewhere that not all the glucosamine is absorbed by the body, depending upon the purity of the glucosamine and the brand, etc…

Regarding the fish oil… well, I just bought whatever brands I found at the pet stoore. At first, I was buying human fish oil in capsules, but Jake would always spit them out… I just preferred less mess and squirted the pet brand salmon fish oil liquid into his food. He had no choice but to eat it.

Angel Jake and Wolfie's Mom

Jake, 10yr old golden retriever (fractured his front right leg on 9/1, bone biopsy revealed osteosarcoma on 9/10, amputation on 9/17) and his family Marguerite, Jacques and Wolfie, 5yr old german shepherd and the newest addition to the family, Nala, a 7mth old Bengal mix kittie. Jake lost his battle on 11/9/2009, almost 8 weeks after his surgery. We will never forget our sweet golden angel… http://jakesjou.....ipawds.com ….. CANCER SUCKS!
6 August 2010
6:09 pm
The Rainbow Bridge

Team Tripawds
Forum Posts: 7621
Member Since:
25 April 2007
Offline

hstanek said:

I don't know how else to title this but if I need to give glucosamine and fish oil – - are all these supplements created equal? 

There's a lot of controversy in this area, but what we have been told by Dr. Jessica Waldman of California Animal Rehabilitation Center is to look for supplements that have been 3rd party tested. She talks about it a bit in this video interview.

Our Nutrition Blog has links to information about supplements too, as well as this article we wrote:

Supplements: How to Spot Bargains Versus Rip-Offs
We found that Synflex Glucosamine Supplements worked GREAT for Jerry and it's a really a good value. We wrote about it a while back:

What is Syn-flex?

For fish oil, we trust K9 Immunity's K9 Omega supplement, which is pill form, but I could see how a liquid version like Jake's Mom said would be nice too. Whatever brand you get, make sure that the bottle they come in is opaque and refrigerate it as soon as you can. Fish oil goes rancid quickly, so don't get more than you can use in a short period of time.

It's better to hop on three legs than to limp on four.™
Latest Tripawds News
Read my story here.
6 August 2010
9:05 pm
Cleveland, OH
Member
Forum Posts: 121
Member Since:
19 June 2010
Offline

Jerry – I looked at Syn-flex and Denali's going on many supplements for pain management and for immune system, so where ever I can "cut costs" and still be effective is VERY important to me as I'm a single-income.  For example, the Syn-flex is $30 for 1 month, a bottle of glucosamine for 180+ pills at Sam's club is only $12-20 depending on brand.  K-9 Omega 3 would last 10 days for me, so that makes it $30 a month, again there are much much cheaper options.  The ACLAIM thing I will take with me, but unfortunately many of the supplements I've seen listed just are simply not in my budget.

~~~~ Denali ~~~~ June 9, 2010 OSA suspected June 17, 2010, July 14, 2010 Clear X-rays – no mets July 1, 2010 Amputation July 9, 2010 OSA Confirmed November 23, 2010 Cancer took you from me - Never forgotten, Always Loved - Forever Supporting the Fighters, Admiring the Survivors, Honoring the Taken, And never, ever giving up Hope
7 August 2010
8:21 am
My heart lives at Rainbow Bridge

Moderator
Forum Posts: 3175
Member Since:
28 November 2008
Offline

For me, supplements are a challenge also.  I think some of the 'hawked' brands for both humans and pets are a rip off.  Asking the pharmasist is a great idea.  I give Trouble the same fish oil I take – just puncture the capsule and pour it on her food and drop the capsule shell in with her food.  For glucosamine I have to use a non-shellfish blend.  I'm using Liquid Health K9 Glucosamine & HA.  You give it by weight and a quart last me about 5-6 weeks for $24.95 + shipping.  They also make a regular with the shellfish that I think is a couple of $$ cheaper, and if I recall correctly you don't give quite as much of  3 tsp for Trouble's weight instead of the 4 tsp she gets of the non-shellfish.  I actually started her out the the glucosamine I take before I discovered it had the shellfish.  I figure if it is ok for me, it's ok for her.

Shanna & Spirit Trouble ~ Trouble gained her wings 3/16/2011, a 27 1/2 month cancer survivor, tail wagging RIP sweetheart, you are my heart and soul.  Run free at Rainbow Bridge.
We honor our fellow November Five members who will always remain forever in my heart: Nova – the lone survivor, live proud and long; Spirits Max, Cherry, & Tika – who made half the journey with us and greeted Trouble at the Bridge
http://k9cancer.org – a canine cancer support community
Forum Timezone: America/Denver

Most Users Ever Online: 165

Currently Online: maggie, justjac
63 Guest(s)

Currently Browsing this Page:
1 Guest(s)

Top Posters:

AngelAbbysMom: 1503

Emilysmom: 1231

fightingforsammy: 1120

jakesmom: 1111

Cooper: 976

10711: 942

riosmom: 939

Cherry: 930

Member Stats:

Guest Posters: 443

Members: 3489

Moderators: 8

Admins: 3

Forum Stats:

Groups: 4

Forums: 22

Topics: 5885

Posts: 81437

Moderators: betaman (91), tazziedog (1232), hugapitbull (3175), testmod (7), Tazzie (1338), cometdog (4147), krun15 (2017), etgayle (1599)

Administrators: jerry (7621), admin (7746), jim (47)